Paul Richards
Dividing the Lib-Con coalition
Kate Green MP
Jonathan Reynolds MP
James Plunkett
Nur Laiq
Hannah Blythyn
Judith Fisher
David Chaplin & Jamie McMahon
Rachel Reeves MP & Ben Fox
Maria Carolina Latorre
News and views from the education frontline
Tom Levitt
Steve Cockburn
Louisa Thomson
Alex Bigham
Rupa Huq
Kezia Dugdale
Dianne Hayter
Nick Smith MP
Chris (Blackpool)
07/09/2010 | 00:55
The Smoking Ban has been a disaster to the Country with 6000...
Chris (Blackpool)
06/09/2010 | 21:53
I'm confused about how this endorsement came about. It is outrageous...
Kirstin Hay (Woking)
06/09/2010 | 18:27
Dont you think we are taxed enough? I pay tax via PAYE, VAT...
Jim Gregg (Luton)
06/09/2010 | 17:58
Labour links
- The Labour party
- Young Labour
- Labour Students
- The Co-op party
- European Parliamentary Labour party
- Party of European Socialists
- Unions Together
- LGA Labour Group
- Change we see
Blogs
- Alastair Campbell
- Anthony Painter
- Bloggers4Labour
- Comment is free
- Conor Ryan
- Cllr Bob Piper
- Boris Watch
- The Daily Dish (Andrew Sullivan)
- Dave Hill's London blog
- Darren Murphy
- David Hencke
- Denis MacShane
- Emma Reynolds MP
- Engage
- The Euston Manifesto
- Fox in parliament
- Euston Manifesto
- Freemania
- Gareth Butler History Trust
- Go Fourth
- Greater Manchester Fabian Society
- Harry's Place
- The Honeyball Buzz
- Hopi Sen
- Kate Green MP
- Kerry McCarthy
- Kezia Dugdale
- LabourHome
- LabourList
- Labour Matters
- Labour Uncut
- LabourWomen
- Left Foot Forward
- Liberal Conspiracy
- Liz Kendall
- Luke Akehurst
- Mark Bennett
- Mike Ion
- Next Left
- Nick Cohen
- NormBlog
- Oliver Kamm
- OpenLeft
- Pat McFadden
- Phillipe Legrain
- Pickled Politics
- Political Hack UK
- Politics for People
- Political Scrapbook
- Rob Carr - A Novocastrian Abroad
- Rob Chesworth
- Robert Sharp
- Rupa Huq
- Sadiq Khan
- Sarah Hayward
- Seema Malhotra
- Stephen Beer
- Tank the Tories
- Theo's Blog
- The Audacity of Pope
- Tim McLoughlin
- Tom Harris
- Tory Stories
- Tory Troll
- ToUChstone blog
- Tygerland
Progressive links
- Christian Socialist Movement
- Democratiya
- Demos
- Fabian Society
- Foreign Policy Centre
- ippr
- Jewish Labour Society
- Labour Campaign for International Development
- Labour Friends of Iraq
- Labour Friends of Israel
- Labour Friends of Palestine & the Middle East
- Labour Humanists
- Labour Uncut
- New Local Government Network
- Policy Network
- Scientists for Labour
- Social Market Foundation
- Smith Institute
- Stephen Twigg for West Derby
- Unions 21
Other Labour Parties
- Irish Labour Party
- Dutch Labour Party
- New Zealand Labour Party
- Australian Labour Party
- Israeli Labour Party
- Maltese Labour Party
Opposition links
Other political links
The economy
Ben Fox
Ideas for Labour to help SMEs recover

Having had the dubious pleasure of reading the coalition's green paper boldly titled ‘Financing a private sector recovery', I can safely say that I haven't read such vacuous contradictory rubbish in a long time.
I'm not quite sure what the coalition is trying to achieve by publishing but - aside from the fact that a few trees have been wasted to produce the document - the content is deeply patronising and offensive to the thousands of British businesses who are desperately seeking capital.
Last week, I had high hopes that by announcing the paper's publication, business secretary Vince Cable recognised the scale of the problem. After all, Saint Vince was the one (albeit self-anointed) who predicted the crisis, and it has become blindingly obvious that the lending crisis is risking Britain's economic recovery. The estimated £1 trillion bank bailout has not led banks to resume lending to businesses, and since the 2008 crisis lending figures have been positive in only three months. The banks claim that there is no demand, while business groups say they are not applying for loans because they expect to be rejected and interest rates are too high.
The paper starts off by stating the glaringly obvious - that "businesses need finances for both working capital and investment purposes" - but that's about as good as it gets. It becomes apparent early on that this paper has George Osborne's fingerprints all over it. There is praise for the banks, but there is nothing here for small businesses: no new instruments to generate lending, no incentives to banks, no new government schemes - nothing.
One of the most shameful points is when the coalition praises banks for having improved their financial position since the crisis - surely not much of a surprise given the amount of cheap money they've borrowed from the bank of England (BoE), and the massive taxpayer bail-out - but then points to the BoE's financial stability report published last month, which states that if major banks limited bonus levels to 2008 levels, they would generate £10 billion of extra capital in 2010 which could sustain £50 billion of new lending. The notion that banks cannot lend because their capital positions are too weak, and there is no demand, is immediately blown out of the water. The money is there, they just would rather pay bonuses than lend to businesses.
As the green paper states, there are around 4.8 million small businesses in the UK, which account for over half the UK's private sector employment and turnover. And the green paper acknowledges their difficulties in accessing capital, adding that SMEs are "vulnerable" and will "face more of a challenge given their reliance on bank lending". It also cites survey evidence from the Warwick business school that many SMEs may have funded themselves through credit cards or overdrafts.
However, it offers no ideas on how to help. Instead, it focuses on accessing debt capital markets and equity markets, which are an alternative to conventional bank lending, but not if you are small business or a start-up. The idea that thousands of businesses of fewer than 10 employees, as most SMEs are, are going to raise millions through venture capital is simply barmy. At one point, having previously stressed the problems lending problems facing SMEs, the coalition paper even performs a complete U-turn, falsely stating that "the majority of businesses can now raise the finance they require" and that "businesses generally are not experiencing severe financial constraint". It really is that bad.
The tragedy is that viable alternatives do exist. The government could offer greater tax incentives to banks to lend, increase the funding and size of the enterprise finances guarantee which is due to expire next March or introduce strong government loan guarantee schemes to encourage banks to provide credit to innovative new businesses.
If, however, these are too complicated or the government deems them too expensive as they embrace austerity, a simple solution is on offer. As we know, taxpayers own large stakes of numerous high-street banks, while the likes of Northern Rock and Bradford and Bingley are effectively entirely nationalised. So, if the conventional financial markets continue to fail and banks refuse to lend, why not convert one of these ‘bailed-out' banks into an industrial investment bank and a green investment bank? These banks would provide a state alternative to the private sector and, most importantly, since both British industry and green technologies are, for different reasons, in need of more than just a ‘quick fix', they would take a medium-term approach to investment.
While some will cringe and think I am talking about creating monolithic centralised state banks, there is no reason for this to be the case. Local authorities and social partners should have a role in the allocation of funds, while decisions could and should be taken at a local rather than centralised level. These institutions could also part of a decentralisation of the banking system, and be combined with regional stock exchanges to help develop regionally focused sources of finance.
Some, many even, will disagree with me about the viability of such vehicles. But, for all its rhetoric, the government simply has no ideas to offer on how to finance a private sector recovery. It is vital that Labour comes up with some.
30 Jul 2010 12:20
Comments
Be the first to comment on this column.
Labour’s record on immigration: Lessons from a turbulent decade - with former Immigration Minister, Barbara Roche
11:30 to 13:00
more » | 0 comments
A round-up of progressive views on the news of the day, given exclusively to ProgressOnline.




Red Wedge: Social Care
Red Wedge: Localism
Become a council candidate…

